Scroll Top

Kazakhstan intelligence chief who was Hunter Biden's 'close friend' and posed with him and Joe is charged with treason during protests that have seen 160 killed and 8,000 arrested

  • Karim Massimov ran Kazakhstan’s National Security Committee until he was fired by the coun­try’s embat­tled pres­i­dent late last week
  • He and oth­er unnamed intel­li­gence offi­cials were arrest­ed the day after firing
  • Hunter Biden once called Massimov a ‘good friend’ in an email from 2016 
  • An undat­ed pho­to appears to show Joe and Hunter Biden smil­ing along­side Kazak busi­ness­man Kenes Rakishev as well as Massimov 
  • It was orig­i­nal­ly pub­lished by an anti-cor­rup­tion group called the Kazakhstani Initiative on Asset Recovery and has not been inde­pen­dent­ly verified 
  • Reports claim that Hunter trav­eled all the way from Paris to Kazakhstan with­out his Secret Service detail in 2014 to dis­cuss a Burisma deal with Massimov 
  • The pho­to resur­faced in 2020 after reports claim­ing that emails found on Hunter’s lap­top could impli­cate Joe in his son’s inter­na­tion­al busi­ness dealings 

Kazakhstan’s for­mer intel­li­gence chief Karim Massimov, who Hunter Biden had described as a ‘close friend,’ was arrest­ed last week and charged with high trea­son as vio­lent anti-gov­ern­ment demon­stra­tions there see more than 160 peo­ple killed and near­ly 8,000 more injured. 

Massimov was arrest­ed on Thursday, his own agency announced over the week­end, toward the end of a week of bloody protests sparked by a vir­tu­al­ly overnight spike in fuel prices. 

On Wednesday he was fired from his role head­ing the Kazakhstan National Security Committee by President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev. He pre­vi­ous­ly served as the coun­try’s prime min­is­ter from 2007 to 2012 and again from 2014 to 2016.

A pho­to unearthed in October 2020 appears to show Joe Biden meet­ing with Massimov and Kenes Rakishev, his son Hunter’s alleged busi­ness part­ner in Kazakhstan. 

Hunter and Massimov report­ed­ly became friend­ly when the then-vice pres­i­den­t’s son served on the board of Ukrainian ener­gy com­pa­ny Burisma and Massimov was in his sec­ond stint as Kazakh prime minister.

The pair met up in Kazakhstan some­time in 2014 to dis­cuss a poten­tial ener­gy deal, emails obtained from Hunter Biden’s lap­top reveal. Hunter alleged­ly skipped out on his Secret Service detail for the pri­vate get-together.

It was in 2016 that the pres­i­den­t’s son called Massimov a ‘close friend.’

An undat­ed pho­to appears to show Joe Biden and his son Hunter (cen­ter) meet­ing with Kazak busi­ness­man Kenes Rakishev (left) and Kazakhstan’s for­mer prime min­is­ter Karim Mossimov (right). The pho­to was first pub­lished on the web­site of an anti-cor­rup­tion group called the Kazakhstani Initiative on Asset Recovery in 2019 and has not been inde­pen­dent­ly verified
Massimov served as Kazakhstan’s prime min­is­ter from 2007 to 2012 and again from 2014 to 2016
In one email from March 15, 2015, Devon Archer — for­mer advis­er to then-Secretary of State John Kerry — for­ward­ed to Hunter an invite from Kazakh banker Marc Holtzman to a ‘small pri­vate break­fast’ with Massimov when he was prime minister

Another email from a for­mer aide of John Kerry’s shows Hunter get­ting invit­ed to a ‘pri­vate break­fast’ with Massimov in 2015 by Kazakh banker Marc Holtzman.

Prime Minister Massimov will be most delight­ed if you will please join us for a small break­fast at one table at the Willard Hotel, Holmes Suite from 8 am until 9 am,’ Holtzman’s email said. 

The National Security Committee, which Massimov ran until the day before his arrest, is Kazakhstan’s nation­al intel­li­gence agency that replaced the Soviet-era KGB after the USSR collapsed. 

There were no details of the trea­son alle­ga­tions against him. The secu­ri­ty ser­vice said oth­er offi­cials were also detained, but did not name them.

On Friday, a pro-gov­ern­ment politi­cian said on tele­vi­sion he had infor­ma­tion that the secu­ri­ty forces had been ordered to aban­don Almaty air­port so pro­test­ers could take it over. He said they had left a secu­ri­ty build­ing in the city unde­fend­ed, enabling peo­ple to seize weapons.

It was not imme­di­ate­ly pos­si­ble to ver­i­fy this account. The air­port remains closed but is now under the con­trol of Kazakh secu­ri­ty per­son­nel and Russian troops, accord­ing to Russia’s defense ministry. 

Protests that were sparked by a near-dou­bling of gas prices were ini­tial­ly peace­ful when they broke out on January 2. But they quick­ly turned vio­lent, becom­ing a broad­er rebuke against Tokayev’s Russian-backed government.

The protests that sparked by high fuel prices in Kazakhstan on January 2 have since seen more than 160 peo­ple killed and near­ly 8,000 detained

As of January 10, Kazakh author­i­ties report­ed that 7,939 peo­ple have been detained and 164 peo­ple were con­firmed dead — includ­ing three children.

The undat­ed pho­to­graph of Massimov and the Bidens, pub­lished in an October 2020 report, resur­faced in the wake of a New York Post report claim­ing that emails found on Hunter’s lap­top could pur­port­ed­ly impli­cate Joe in his embat­tled son’s inter­na­tion­al busi­ness deal­ings dur­ing his time as vice president. 

In the image — which was pub­lished on the web­site of an anti-cor­rup­tion group called the Kazakhstani Initiative on Asset Recovery and has not been inde­pen­dent­ly ver­i­fied — Joe and Hunter are seen smil­ing along­side Rakishev and Mossimov. lift­ed the lid on Hunter’s alleged rela­tion­ship with Rakishev last week, reveal­ing that between 2012 and 2014 the for­mer VP’s son worked as a sort of go-between help­ing the Kazak busi­ness­man bro­ker US investments. 

Emails passed to The Mail via anti-cor­rup­tion cam­paign­ers from the Central Asian coun­try revealed that Hunter held exten­sive meet­ings with Rakishev, who has close fam­i­ly ties to the klep­to­crat­ic regime of his home­land’s despot­ic for­mer pres­i­dent Nursultan Nazarbayev. lift­ed the lid on Hunter’s alleged rela­tion­ship with Rakishev (pic­tured) last week

Hunter also trav­eled to the Kazakh cap­i­tal of Astana to hold busi­ness dis­cus­sions with Rakishev, who was appar­ent­ly look­ing to invest a por­tion of his per­son­al for­tune in New York and Washington DC. 

Hunter then attempt­ed to per­suade Rakishev to buy into a Nevadan min­ing com­pa­ny, bro­ker­ing a series of meet­ings with the firm, before con­vinc­ing him to invest a cool mil­lion dol­lars with Alexandra Forbes Kerry, the film-mak­er daugh­ter of Democrat Senator and for­mer Presidential can­di­date John Kerry.

Rakishev, who wrote mes­sages in bro­ken English, appeared to have become inti­mate with the vice pres­i­den­t’s son, call­ing Hunter ‘my broth­er!’ and ‘my broth­er from anoth­er mother!’

They shared gos­sip about their fam­i­ly hol­i­days and dined togeth­er at lux­u­ry restau­rants in New York and Washington DC (‘I’m on vaca­tion with fam­i­ly [at] Lake Michigan … try­ing to spend some much need­ed time with my wife and daugh­ters. It’s my 20th anniver­sary of mar­riage tomor­row,’ Hunter told Rakishev in July 2013).

The unver­i­fied pho­to fueled spec­u­la­tion that Hunter may have dragged his father into the oli­garch’s orbit as well — deep­en­ing a long-stand­ing con­tro­ver­sy over Hunter’s over­seas busi­ness deal­ings when Joe was VP.

Joe Biden and his son Hunter are fac­ing renewed scruti­ny relat­ed to Hunter’s busi­ness deal­ings over­seas after his aban­doned lap­top was found to hold e‑mails that alleged­ly show Joe Biden was in on Hunter’s deals. Joe Biden’s cam­paign has denied any wrongdoing

Hunter has for years been crit­i­cized for his lucra­tive but eth­i­cal­ly ques­tion­able work over­seas, which has often cre­at­ed appar­ent con­flicts of inter­est with Joe’s offi­cial roles. 

The Biden cam­paign was rocked by a vin­tage ‘October sur­prise’ last week when a New York Post expose claimed that Hunter’s lap­top was aban­doned at the com­put­er shop in April 2019 for months and was found to con­tain emails that could impli­cate Joe. 

The lap­top’s hard dri­ve was obtained by Donald Trump’s per­son­al lawyer Rudy Giuliani, who shared its con­tents with the Post. 

Senior fed­er­al offi­cials told Fox News on Tuesday that the FBI is now in pos­ses­sion of the com­put­er and con­firmed that Hunter’s emails are ‘authen­tic’.  

The emails indi­cat­ed that Hunter intro­duced his father Vadym Pozharskyi of Burisma Holdings, the Ukrainian ener­gy com­pa­ny that Hunter served on the board of, in 2015. 

The pur­port­ed meet­ing alleged­ly took place a year before Joe pres­sured Ukrainian gov­ern­ment offi­cials to fire the pros­e­cu­tor involved in an inves­ti­ga­tion of Burisma. 

In one email, Pozharskyi wrote: ‘Dear Hunter, thank you for invit­ing me to DC and giv­ing an oppor­tu­ni­ty to meet your father and spent some time togeth­er. It’s real­ty [sic] an hon­or and pleasure.’ 

The email did not state that the two actu­al­ly met, and the Biden cam­paign respond­ed that ‘we have reviewed Joe Biden’s offi­cial sched­ules from the time and no meet­ing, as alleged by the New York Post, ever took place.’ 

But the cam­paign lat­er con­ced­ed that they could­n’t rule out that the meet­ing may have happened. 

Other emails pur­port­ed­ly sent by Hunter showed him lever­ag­ing his dad’s office to boost his pay on Burisma’s board. 

The FBI has declined to con­firm whether or not it is exam­in­ing Hunter’s lap­top and its contents. 

It comes hours after for­mer President Trump demand­ed that Attorney General Bill Barr ‘act fast’ and appoint a spe­cial coun­sel to probe his Democratic rival before Election Day.

Then-Donald Trump said he want­ed attor­ney gen­er­al Bill Barr to name a spe­cial pros­e­cu­tor to probe the Bidens 

Trump called for Barr to appoint some­one to probe the lap­top, which has become the sub­ject of repeat­ed Trump attacks on his rival after Giuliani hand­ed over the con­tents to the Post. 

The ex-pres­i­dent said it revealed ‘major cor­rup­tion’ and that it has to come out before the election.

Trump has yet to spec­i­fy what crime he believes the Bidens have com­mit­ted, but that has not stopped him from going as far as sug­gest­ing to vot­ers that Biden belongs in jail. 

His demand would appear to run smack into a Justice Department pol­i­cy against tak­ing actions that would inter­fere in an elec­tion – an issue that played out in 2016 in both the Hillary Clinton email probe and the then-unknown Russia probe.

We’ve got to get the attor­ney gen­er­al to act. He’s got to act. And he’s got to act fast. He’s got to appoint some­body,’ Trump said when asked about nam­ing a spe­cial coun­sel on Fox & Friends. 

Who is Kenes Rakishev? The Kazak businessman who ‘hired Hunter Biden as a go-between for brokering US investments’ 

Reporting by Guy Adams for The Daily Mail 

Kenes Rakishev’s rela­tion­ship with Hunter Biden was laid bare in emails obtained by the Daily Mail last week amid a deep­en­ing scan­dal sur­round­ing Hunter’s over­seas busi­ness dealings. 

The Mail revealed that between 2012 and 2014, Hunter worked as a sort of go-between for Rakishev, a self-styled ‘inter­na­tion­al busi­ness­man, investor and entre­pre­neur’ with close fam­i­ly con­nec­tions to the klep­to­crat­ic regime of his home­land’s despot­ic for­mer pres­i­dent Nursultan Nazarbayev. 

In the UK, Rakishev is per­haps best known due to a bizarre 2008 episode when he’d helped a fel­low oli­garch chum called Timur Kulibayev use a firm reg­is­tered in the British Virgin Islands buy a home from Prince Andrew: his Windsor man­sion Sunninghill Park, which odd­ly went for £15million, some £3million over the ask­ing price.

Coverage of the episode had not­ed that Kulibayev was the son-in-law of the afore­men­tioned despot Nazarbayev, who ruled Kazakhstan for more than two decades, turn­ing it into one of the world’s most cor­rupt kleptocracies.

Rakishev, for his part, is mar­ried to the daugh­ter of a for­mer may­or of the coun­try’s cap­i­tal city (recent­ly re-named ‘Nursultan,’ after the elder­ly despot), who lat­er served as its Defence Minister and Deputy Prime Minister. 

The Mail revealed that between 2012 and 2014, Hunter worked as a sort of go-between for Rakishev (pic­tured), a self-styled ‘inter­na­tion­al busi­ness­man, investor and entre­pre­neur’ with close fam­i­ly con­nec­tions to the klep­to­crat­ic regime of his home­land’s despot­ic for­mer pres­i­dent Nursultan Nazarbayev

Fast for­ward to 2012 and Rakishev had just joined Forbes mag­a­zine’s top-15 list of Kazakhstan’s ‘most influ­en­tial’ tycoons, with esti­mat­ed assets of some $332million. Like many an oli­garch in pos­ses­sion of a huge for­tune, Rakishev was now look­ing for a safe place to park it, so had come to America in search of new places to invest his hard-earned roubles.

Sadly, things had­n’t gone entire­ly smooth­ly. For in the high­ly-reg­u­lat­ed world of Western cap­i­tal­ism, Rakishev dis­cov­ered that blue-chip invest­ment part­ners were often reluc­tant to take his cash.

To blame? The fact that no one was entire­ly sure where his wealth actu­al­ly came from.

For exam­ple, the leaked emails obtained by the Mail show that the International Finance Corporation, a high­ly respectable sis­ter organ­i­sa­tion of the World Bank, held pre­lim­i­nary talks with Rakishev about a busi­ness col­lab­o­ra­tion, before decid­ing to pull out.

The IFC then polite­ly informed the oli­garch that it ‘can­not invest with him’ because its ‘very deep due dili­gence process­es’ had estab­lished that he had some ‘con­nec­tions’ involv­ing the ‘pres­i­den­t’s fam­i­ly’ that ‘are a lia­bil­i­ty to us’.

Seemingly out­raged, Rakishev respond­ed that he would ensure that the orga­ni­za­tion ‘nev­er works in Kazakhstan with anyone.’

The United States Department of Justice then took an inter­est in Rakishev. It soon dragged him into an inves­ti­ga­tion of poten­tial breach­es the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act relat­ed to ‘an invest­ment in the oil and gas indus­try in Kazakhstan’.

Though Rakishev imme­di­ate­ly denied all wrong­do­ing, and no charges were ever filed, in September 2013 he decid­ed to hire a noto­ri­ous­ly expen­sive US law firm called Greenberg Traurig to deal with incom­ing fire relat­ed to the probe.

It seems that two attor­neys who led a team work­ing the Kazakh’s case, John Pappalardo and Stanford Saunders, charged him in the region of $1,000 and $700 per hour respectively.

It was, doubt­less, a very annoy­ing (and expen­sive) busi­ness; not to men­tion high­ly frus­trat­ing for a man who had per­haps grown used to get­ting his own way. Which is per­haps what per­suad­ed him to take meet­ings with Hunter Biden, a mem­ber of one of America’s most pow­er­ful polit­i­cal dynasties.

In May 2012, he was emailed by Hunter’s busi­ness part­ner Devon Archer, a lawyer and for­mer Abercrombie & Fitch mod­el. ‘Can you have din­ner with me, Hunter Biden, Alex [Forbes Kerry] and team on Wednesday next week in NYC? I want to let Hunter know when he should come up from DC to see you on Wednesday. Looking for­ward to see­ing you!’

Rakishev replied: ‘Hi Devon! I would be hap­py to have a din­ner with you and all our friends! Thank you very much for invi­ta­tions! Take care my brother!’

By July, Hunter had trav­elled to Astana to dis­cuss busi­ness oppor­tu­ni­ties. ‘I want­ed to check in with you and see what our next steps are to fol­low up on our vis­it to Kazakhstan,’ he wrote in an email to Rakishev sent short­ly after­wards. ‘Let me know if you need any­thing from me.’

Three months lat­er, Biden was help­ing Rakishev hold dis­cus­sions about invest­ing in Prospect Global Resources, a potash min­ing firm based in east­ern Arizona.

Although the emails the Mail has seen show that the talks even­tu­al­ly broke down, he remained on friend­ly terms: ‘I want­ed to reach back out to you and con­tin­ue our con­ver­sa­tions,’ Hunter wrote to Kulibayev on November 25, 2012. 

I under­stand you and Timur eval­u­at­ed PGRX but it was not a good fit at this time. Thank you for tak­ing a look at it and for the quick feed­back as well. Let me know when you’d like to connect.’

The duo remained in close con­tact through­out the fol­low­ing year, dis­cussing a range of busi­ness ventures.

Then, in late October 2013, Biden’s part­ner Archer arranged a con­fer­ence call between Rakishev and the afore­men­tioned Alex Forbes Kerry, who was by then attempt­ing to raise cash to launch a film pro­duc­tion firm.

Immediately after the call that December, Rakishev emailed with hap­py news: ‘Thank you my broth­er from anoth­er moth­er! Thanks you very much my broth­er! We decid­ed to invest 1 mln [mil­lion]! Give them my email!’

Forbes Kerry, who has nev­er pub­licly acknowl­edged her debt to Rakishev, finalised the deal in January 2014. The fol­low­ing month, she and Biden met Rakishev for din­ner in Washington DC.

It was a plea­sure to meet you with Devon and Hunter the oth­er day,’ she told him by email after­wards. ‘I want to thank you for the beau­ti­ful watch! I am sor­ry I did­n’t open it at the table. I mis­un­der­stood and thought it was a baby present so I only opened it when I was at home. It is absolute­ly beau­ti­ful and you are so gen­er­ous … Please come to New York soon and bring your fam­i­ly. We will host you and your team.’

Rakishev respond­ed that he intend­ed to take up that offer in September. ‘Let’s be in touch!’ he wrote.

Sadly, at the time of this hap­py exchange, Biden’s mar­riage was in the process of break­ing down. Things cul­mi­nat­ed in a spec­tac­u­lar­ly hos­tile divorce in which his wife Kathleen claimed he had spent ‘extrav­a­gant­ly on his own inter­ests (includ­ing drugs, alco­hol, pros­ti­tutes, strip clubs, and gifts for women with whom he has sex­u­al rela­tions), while leav­ing the fam­i­ly with no mon­ey to pay legit­i­mate bills’. 

Original source of arti­cle:

Related Posts